Is Fiberglass or Wood Better for an Exterior Door?

New front entry door on a nice house.

When it comes to entry door replacement, choosing which material can be as important as choosing the overall style. Many homeowners find themselves choosing between fiberglass and wood for their exterior doors. Is one better than the other?

What are the Key Factors in Entry Door Replacement?

There are several factors that go into choosing your new front door. Your front door is the focal point of your home that most people will notice when they approach or drive by. Your home’s curb appeal is a factor that can’t be ignored. The look and design is important. Another key point is security. The material you choose can have an impact on how safe your home is for you and your family. Keeping intruders and pests out of your home is important, and the material you choose will play a role in how secure the door is. Finally, energy efficiency is something you need to consider.

Pros of Fiberglass Doors

Fiberglass doors are available in styles to fit every home exterior. There is a wide range of looks, colors, and finishes. Fiberglass can easily be repainted if you’d like a fresher look. It resists dents, scratches, rust, and rot. It will never warp due to water or temperature. A fiberglass door gets high ratings for energy efficiency, too. A windowless fiberglass door can offer five times the insulating value of a solid wood door. When properly installed, fiberglass doors offer superior security. Composite door frames have twice the holding power of wood. Fiberglass doors will last a long time, since they aren’t prone to damage.

Cons of Fiberglass Doors

Fiberglass doors offer plenty of pros, but they do come at a cost. A quality fiberglass door is an investment. Yes, bargain fiberglass doors exist, but these doors will not offer the same advantages as a higher quality one, and any initial savings may be offset by the need for early repairs or replacement. Fiberglass doors also may not work well in older homes. They are usually manufactured with an attached frame, and older homes without standard size doors may require a more complicated installation.

Pros of Wood Doors

A wood door has a beautiful look. A wood door compliments many design styles and is a classic touch. Wood can be modern, traditional, or rustic. Wood can be customized with paint or stain to fit the design of your home. Wood doors are excellent for noisy neighborhoods as they greatly reduce the noise from outside. This may be a significant consideration for those homes on busy streets. Wood can be customized to any size doorway, and can be repaired easily if issues arise.

Cons of Wood Doors

While there are plenty of positive things about wood doors, there are drawbacks as well. Wood doors are susceptible to moisture and the damage that moisture can bring. They may begin to warp or bubble, and although they keep outdoor noise out, they are not as energy efficient. Wood doors will require more maintenance. You will need to reseal them every few years and touch up the stain or paint. Wood doors are often expensive, too.

Determining Which Door is Right for You

When it comes to deciding on what you are looking for in entry door replacement, both wood and fiberglass can be logical choices. Consider your specific needs. Are you interested in noise reduction? Is energy efficiency your primary concern? What is the age and style of your home? What is your budget for the door?

When figuring out which material you want for your entry door replacement, there are many good options. It’s important to talk to a professional about your situation and what is most important to you. Taking a good look at your budget, design choice, and energy needs can guide you in the right direction. At Armorvue, we carry high quality replacement doors and can help you make the right choice for your family and your home. Contact us today for a virtual appointment to talk about replacing your entry door, or any other exterior home improvement project you’ve been thinking about.